commentr/StutterJanuary 7, 2024

Content

>"Because when someone says "accept the way things are", I think they mean that you should just be okay with your lot in life. If you have condition that has no known cure, you should focus on coping with it and living with it. That's what comes to mind when I conceptualize acceptance." I tend to agree with you. Despite my aversion to it, I perceive that some PWS link acceptance to closing the door to subconscious fluency, or they link it to reinforcing the concept of stuttering anticipation by believing that stuttering will likely persist. Walking with closed eyes and bowed head, ignorant of the negative ramifications in the shape of impaired neural adaptations that come with it. Even if we would incorporate the concept of 'acceptance' from the realm of [mindfulness](https://i.imgur.com/n8PZizO.jpg), anticipating that we will (always) stutter inherently places us in a future mindset, in contrast, mindfulness encourages being in the present moment. >" Does it mean you should give up on searching for a cure or solution when things seem impossible?" I find terms such as "cure," "recovery," or "fluency" to be insufficient and often inadequate. Rather, I prefer to use the terminology: applying helpful interventions to instruct execution of speech motor plans, and address its neural disruptions. I believe that most PWS are not able to recognize, when they are actually (1) instructing execution of motor plans, (2) reacting to its disruptions, or (3) implementing inhibitory control (such as, stalling the motor execution). They are so tunnel-visioned on threat detection > avoidance-struggle-coping responses, that they entirely overlook these three key elements of subconscious fluency. >"Although by adaptive, it could mean filler words, replacing words to avoid blocking on a word, or even avoiding certain speaking situations." If I consider the second line "acceptance is not running away", I view this as, don't use avoidance responses, but more specifically.. don't avoid the initial speech plan. Note, the following interventions by definition, leads to avoiding the initial desired speech plan: * secondary, coping, struggle or avoidance responses (such as the ones you pointed out) * speech techniques like fluency shaping or reducing speech rate with the goal of executing motor plans (obviously, this avoids the initial speech plan) * reducing fear of communication failure specifically to execute motor plans (such as, anticipation of stuttering or negative listener responses) (this avoids fear, and other triggers which counters desensitization) >Maybe a better term would be "heatlthy" or "constructive" or "empowering" instead of adaptive? Yes indeed, but **healthy** depends on the fluency goal (which is not subconscious fluency, at least almost invariably PWS do not act upon this goal it would seem). Therefore, PWS will likely not perceive the three key element as healthy.

Themes

Identity & DisabilityCoping & AdvocacyAnticipation & Avoidance

Subthemes

Acceptance & PrideMindset shiftOverthinking & Monitoring