Can definitely feel you on the cringe. I remember when I tried online dating when I was 18 or so and I was hitting it off with some girl. Then she told me to leave her a voice message on her phone. You can imagine how it went. From there she outright insulted me and told me she played it for all her friends, ha. In return I commented on her weight. Good memory. However, I don't think stuttering is a turnoff for many girls. I know my most recent long-term girlfriend was very attracted to it. It makes you memorable, at least, and that's an advantage in the sexual marketplace. You could still have a chance with picture girl.